Pierogi Recipe (VIDEO)

These homemade Pierogi filled with cheesy potatoes, tossed with crisp bacon and melted butter, and served with sour cream is the ultimate comfort food. They can be served as the main dish or as an irresistible side.

Pierogi are as classic to Eastern European cuisine as Stuffed Cabbage Rolls, Piroshki, and Schnitzel. They will never go out of style. Watch the video tutorial and you’ll be enjoying pierogi in no time.

This post may contain affiliate links. Read my disclosure policy.

What Are Pierogi?

Pierogi are dumplings with a tender dough and savory or sweet fillings, similar to ravioli. They are boiled in water and tossed in butter to serve. Pierogi are a staple in Eastern European countries, especially Poland, where they are the national food, but we grew up eating them in Ukraine, and they are well-loved throughout the world.

Most Americans know them as Polish pierogi and buy “Mrs. T Pierogies” (a sad store-bought version), but my homemade pierogi (or Ukrainian “Vareniki”) will blow the frozen ones out of the water!

Pierogi Recipe Video

See how easy it is to make homemade pierogi with Natasha’s classic recipe! Be sure to note her tip on how to make the pretty fluted edge and easy stuffing using her favorite mini-scoop to add the potato filling. Now gather some friends, and let’s get rolling!

*Note that we updated the recipe in 2024 to include more oil for a softer and more tender dough and knead the dough for less time.

The Best Pierogi Recipe

If you haven’t tried pierogi before, you’re about to fall in love. These are the best of a warm, cheesy loaded baked potato in a bite-sized dumpling. This pierogi recipe makes 50-60 perfect dumplings, enough to freeze for later or serve a large crowd.

Growing up, this potato pierogi recipe, or “Vareniki” was my favorite, so it was a no-brainer that it needed to be included in Natasha’s Kitchen Cookbook. My Mother and sisters rolled huge batches of pierogi dough, stuffing, and expertly molding them. Each buttery batch disappeared so fast! These days my kids love rolling the dough and crimping every dough pocket.

Ingredients

You’ll love the simplicity of the ingredients – they are pantry and refrigerator staples.

• Liquid Ingredients – combining warm water, milk and sour cream adds fat to the dough and flavor.
• Oil – we use extra light olive oil, but any mild-flavored oil will work. The oil makes the dough very soft and easy to roll out.
• Egg – binds the dough, room temperature eggs mix more easily
• Salt – adds flavor to the dough and cooking water
• Flour – all-purpose flour works great but measure correctly so the dough isn’t dense.
• Potato Filling – we combine russet potatoes, salt, butter, and cheese. Russets will give you the smoothest and creamiest filling. Our go-to cheeses are cream cheese and mozzarella but you can substitute with cheddar, havarti, or your favorite cheese.

Can I use Leftover Mashed Potatoes?

As a shortcut, use leftover mashed potatoes for the filling (avoid instant or flaked potatoes), just be sure they aren’t overly creamy or soft, which can make the pierogi fall apart. To use leftover mashed potatoes for pierogi, simply omit the butter from the filling and be sure the leftover mashed potatoes are cold when mixing.

Tips for Making Perfect Pierogi

This recipe makes the best pierogi! If you’re new to making pierogi or want to perfect your skills, here are some tips to ensure success:

• Don’t overcook potatoes – they can become waterlogged and too loose.
• Avoid over-kneading dough that develops gluten making it tough, chewy, and difficult to roll out.
• Rest the dough – this allows the gluten to relax, making it much easier to roll out.
• Keep the dough covered – wrap it in plastic when not actively using it so it doesn’t dry out.
• Roll dough thinly – it should be about 1/8″ thick. If it’s too thick, it can seem dense.
• Keep dough edges clear – don’t overfill, and avoid getting potato or any filling on the edges of the dough circles or it will be difficult to seal. I use this mini-scoop to help with clean portioning, but you can use a couple of teaspoons to portion.
• Tightly seal – I prefer to double crimp (go over the edges twice) to ensure a tight seal so the contents don’t seep out while boiling
• Cook in Batches – Don’t overcrowd your pot; allow the pierogi some room to float to the top.
• Don’t overcook pierogi – if the dough gets too soft, the filling might escape into the cooking water.
• Butter right away – toss freshly cooked pierogi with melted butter to prevent sticking.

How to Freeze Pierogi

This recipe makes a large batch, so you can make the pierogi ahead and cook when you’re ready to eat. 

• After shaping the dumplings, dust a baking sheet with flour and arrange the pierogi so they aren’t touching. Loosely cover with plastic wrap and freeze for 2 hours or until firm.
• Once frozen, transfer to a large freezer-safe zip-top bag to store for up to 3 months.
• When ready to cook, drop the frozen pierogis into the boiling water and continue with the recipe per the instructions.

What to Serve with Pierogi

These cheesy pierogi can be served as a side dish or the main course. We include a dollop or bowl of sour cream for dipping. Other dipping options include butter sauce or plain yogurt.

To serve as a side, build your Eastern European menu with these traditional pairings for pierogi:

• Sautéed Mushrooms
• Borscht
• Creamy Cucumber Salad
• Marinated Mini Bell Peppers
• Sauerkraut
• Homemade Kielbasa
• Buckwheat

You are sure to fall in love with this pierogi recipe immediately! The cheesy potato filling and bacon-butter topping make these pierogies irresistible. Grab a few extra hands, and roll these delicious dumplings today!